1

I though this question could use a tag about intonation: Guitar isn't playing in tune

The problem is that "intonation" can be used differently in other musical contexts, such as in singing. So we'd need or something like that. I'm also not sure whether is sufficient. Obviously tuning in general is a superset of tuning for intonation, but I'm not sure if it would be better to have a specific tag as well.

2

[tuning], [repair], and [maintenance] are a bit too general for this purpose. There are many questions already about tuning the guitar and dealing with tuning problems, and they're not the same thing as setting the intonation on a guitar (even though badly set intonation can cause tuning problems). Intonation on guitars and bass guitars is a bit of a black art, and one most players will encounter eventually. However, the [intonation] tag clearly isn't going to work now.

I recommend using [fretboard-intonation] as the tag for this concept: It's clear, and would apply to guitars, bass guitars, mandolins, ukeleles; anything with frets and a bridge.

  • 1
    That makes sense. +1, I'll wait on doing this to see if there are any other ideas. – Matthew Read May 28 '11 at 15:01
1

Although [intonation] in itself is unclear, the combination of [guitar] and [intonation] isn't. But a guitarist is unlikely to search for [guitar-intonation]. So I think [intonation] can be used with no problems here.

-1

I'd probably have used the or tags (because to me, it seems like that poster's instrument is broken our otherwise not in proper working order), but is a good choice.

  • 2
    Hmm. I think the answer might be repair or maintenance, but I'm not sure the question is about either of those. – Matthew Read May 28 '11 at 0:53

You must log in to answer this question.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged .