What are our thoughts on "What is my vocal type?" questions? Should these be considered on topic or off?
I ask because, invariably, the answers tend to be something along the lines of:
Well, we can't really say. You should get a teacher!
And thus our answers aren't real answers per se. At what point should something like this be moved to the "questions not to ask" list?
Edit: The most detailed answers along this track that I've found are:
- How do I determine my vocal range?
- What is the process by which singers identify their voice type/fach?
- Whats my vocal type?
In light of Dan's very helpful suggestion, I'll let the moderator team decide if we need a new question/answer that incorporates information from all of these three threads.