(This question shows up on every SE meta site sooner or later, but the system won’t let it be deleted now that it has a constructive answer.)

Why is someone downvoting my answers without commenting? I am a devoted musician with helpful hints, time tested and taught successfully. Some of my techniques are shortcuts, admittedly, but they can help a learning player break through a barrier or two.

Uncommented negative votes (some have been reversed by now, perhaps after I had to figure out without help how to reword answers) undermine the well-intentioned content of an answer. Why can't these be conversed?

I am not here to scoop up points, but I sincerely want to share the benefit of what I’ve been taught, of what I’ve learned, and what I’ve stumbled across. Please let my answers settle at 0 votes. If you go negative, please leave a constructive comment. I am also here to learn.

| |
  • 5
    I'm in the same position as you in terms of being a devoted musician with a lot of knowledge and many uncommented downvotes. All I've done differently is review anything I've written that has been downvoted and either edit it or ignore the downvotes, and I've kept doing that and now here I am with a respectable amount of rep. They are just votes. Nothing more. – Todd Wilcox May 23 '17 at 4:04
  • 2
    @musicn it only does harm if you take it personally or if it is misused. Voting up and down is very important on SE sites and I would argue misplaced upvote does way more harm than a misplaced down vote and no one ever questions up votes they receive. If you don't receive a comment, take a step back reread the question and how your answer applies to it. – Dom May 23 '17 at 4:44
  • I wish I had differentiated between an uncommented downvote that dilutes upvotes – well received – and an uncommented downvote that results in a negative faceplate – a cheap shot. I'm trying to rewrite everything in terms of that difference. Currently in the works: "I believe that a well-intentioned answer with uncommented negativity diminishes this site's credibility." @Dom? – lauir May 28 '17 at 22:41
  • 5
    @musicn don't associate downvotes with negativity. They are very different. When used correctly they are very positive in nature in keeping the quality of the site at its highest potential . I'm not saying they cannot be used for the wrong reasons, but so can up votes. There can be a lot of reasons not to comment after voting one way or another one which is fear of retaliation from other users so please let's not persecute every down vote. – Dom May 29 '17 at 0:25
  • 2
    If one of my answers has a down vote I do like Todd and control my answer. Very often I find an error or a typo, sometimes even a mistake in my thinking, and if not I try to emphasize my statement somehow. – Albrecht Hügli Sep 24 '19 at 8:28

The whole point of Stack Exchange is to vote for the post NOT the author. You may be a devoted musician, but that doesn't mean your posts are going to be right for everyone, or appropriate to that particular scenario.

If someone disagrees with a point, or dislikes it, or in fact just wants to downvote it, they can.

Conversely, if someone likes a post or just wants to give you an upvote they can. But guidance is definitely not to give upvotes just because someone asks for them!

We deliberately do not enforce commenting though. Votes are anonymous for a purpose.

As Richard pointed out, you have only had 2 downvotes. That is so low as to be almost irrelevant. Just don't worry about it. Over time, votes will reflect the value of a post.

| |
  • ^vote with a note: I'm not asking for ^votes, just not to have potentially useful answers marred by uncommented type-by downvotes. (Again, nothing new for SE. I assume that everyone's contributions here are meant to help and nothing else.) And certainly anonymity is worth protecting. Evidence our user names. I would like to encourage, not enforce, commenting. (Sorry about the serial comment revisions.) – lauir May 22 '17 at 20:45
  • @musicn A down vote doesn't mar an answer. The only thing that mars an answer on SE is a bad edit. – Todd Wilcox May 23 '17 at 3:58
  • @Todd Wilcox, Now I'm working on the distinction between a less positive score, which is so harmless as to be constructive, and a downright negative score, which I still believe is harmful. Thank you for staying tuned – lauir May 28 '17 at 22:45
  • 2
    It is just a down vote. If you write better answers you get less downvotes. Remember you are not the judge of your own posts - everyone else is. – Doktor Mayhem May 28 '17 at 22:59
  • There is no way for you to distinguish between a downvote diluting other votes and a "cheap shot" – Doktor Mayhem May 28 '17 at 23:00
  • 1
    So please don't try to make a distinction. Just focus on writing good posts and don't worry about the occasional down vote – Doktor Mayhem May 28 '17 at 23:01
  • 1
    @musicn It's like putting out a work of music. No matter how great or terrible you know it to be, because you crafted it, you can't argue either way with how people like or dislike it. Some of my least favorite songs that I've written, like some of my least favorite answers, are actually the most popular (none of the songs I've written are popular beyond 100 people or so, just to be clear). You have no control over what other people think, so concerning yourself too much with what they think is a road to madness. – Todd Wilcox May 28 '17 at 23:56
  • Perhaps I've miscalibrated the rate of traffic on this site, @Todd Wilcox. I just don't want well-intentioned material to fall by the wayside. After all, music is at stake! (Overstated o lo boffo, if no obvioso.) – lauir May 30 '17 at 1:19
  • (Sorry about the misspelling: "boffo" = "buffo" = "buffoonish," not "box-office bonanza." No questions here yet about "basso buffo"? Opera omnia!) – lauir May 30 '17 at 1:34
  • It's better to be a devotet than a downvoted musician. – Albrecht Hügli Sep 24 '19 at 8:29

My most-downvoted answer is how do I compute midi stop time - a topic that I know a fair bit about. I've written more than one piece of MIDI software.

My most-upvoted answer is What do 'vent holes' do on a music stand? - a random guess at a topic I know nothing about.

Voting on this site can be pretty random. Don't worry about it!

| |
  • My guess on this is that the down-voters on the MIDI question does not understand much about the subject, and didn't feel they learned anything from your answer, because it was a bit verbose. – awe May 29 '17 at 11:11
  • On the music stand question, it is a topic that a lot of people can grasp the context of, and you made some good assuptions that seems to be logic to a lot of people - thus the high number of up-votes.. – awe May 29 '17 at 11:13
  • I could get angry when an answer is down-voted for which I have investigated a lot researching and a lot of time, also written and explained a whole article while a I am upvoted for a simple answer to a simple question about something elementary that everyone should know. In the first case I don't worry and say to me: At least I have learnt a lot. In the second case I'll write it as a comment and give a chance to others to answer. What I've learnt most especially by downvotes is to read better the question and try to understand what OP is asking. The problem I have in my daily life: Listen! – Albrecht Hügli Sep 24 '19 at 8:38

As far as I can tell, you've only received two downvotes: one in Is there any scientific reason why three notes are seen as required to create an 'unambiguous' harmony? (which was mediated by an upvote), and one in Trumpet - Trouble with high notes?

That's two downvotes from 11 questions, with a net vote count of +27 for your 11 answers, which is actually pretty good for our community.

Don't beat yourself up; we're glad you're here!

(PS: I loved your answer at Why are time signatures not used in this score? and I couldn't believe I didn't spot this myself!)

| |
  • Thank you for scanning the log, Richard. I should've included links in the question. Never too late (but not the time at the moment). – lauir May 22 '17 at 19:40

You must log in to answer this question.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged .