4

I came out with this question. It came to the chat, and I asked, if this question belongs to Sound Design SE or if it is allowed here.

Then @DrMayhem said:

I don't think that question would work on SD. It isn't about sound design. Here, I don't really think it works that well either

The Audio & Video Production SE became Video Production right?

But the Sound Design SE don't clarify their on-topic question. Then, I go down to the search, find this and this question, it is allowed there, but when I check the on-topic question (thanks to @Meaningful). It says:

and it is not about...

  • identifying a song, genre, instrument, etc.
  • shopping, product or music search, or buying/selling recommendations
  • audio production techniques and equipment
  • listening recommendations or recommendations of pieces to play
  • requesting a list of resources
  • legal issues

So, do question like that on-topic or allowed here?

8

As long as you're recording music, or sound for use in music, or it's applicable to recording music, then such a question is definitely on-topic here. We used to refer people to Audio and later AVP sometimes in case they could get better expert answers, but obviously we can't do that anymore.

  • 1
    Makes sense. But what is the "audio production techniques and equipment" intended to discourage then? – Meaningful Username May 26 '14 at 17:44
  • 5
    @MeaningfulUsername I think that just need to be updated. Even originally it was a poor way to distinguish us from the other site. I've removed it :) – Matthew Read May 26 '14 at 17:57

You must log in to answer this question.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged .